107ready logo ready

Part 107 News

Supreme Court leaves the Texas drone no-fly and surveillance law in place

In effect

Event date:

Published:

Chapter 423 of the Texas Government Code governs drone flights in Texas. A group of journalists and press associations challenged two sets of its provisions.

  • The surveillance provisions make it an offense, when the intent is to conduct surveillance, to capture an image of a person or private property with a drone.
  • The no-fly provisions: under them it is an offense to fly a drone at or below 400 feet above ground level over a critical infrastructure facility or a sports venue. There is an exception for flights for a commercial purpose by an operator who complies with the applicable FAA rules and authorizations.
  • Prisons and detention facilities were moved into the Texas Penal Code from September 1, 2023, and, the court noted, no longer appear to carry the commercial exception.

A violation is a criminal offense and can also bring civil liability.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed a 2022 ruling against the law. Its substituted opinion, filed January 10, 2024 in No. 22-50337, replaced its October 2023 panel opinion. It sent the case back with instructions to enter judgment for Texas on the constitutional claims. It also rejected the argument that federal aviation law preempts the state law: “federal law expressly contemplates concurrent non-federal regulation of drones”. DroneLife reported the October 2023 ruling two days later.

The National Press Photographers Association asked the Supreme Court to hear the case on April 9, 2024 (No. 23-1105). The Court denied the petition on October 7, 2024, so the Fifth Circuit’s ruling stands.

What this means for Part 107 pilots and test takers

In Texas, flying at or below 400 feet over a covered critical infrastructure facility or sports venue is a crime unless the flight is for a commercial purpose and complies with FAA rules and authorizations. Over prisons and detention facilities, that exception no longer appears to apply. The ruling also means FAA rules don’t automatically override a state drone law, so check the law of the state you fly in. State laws aren’t on the knowledge test.